Extending the properties of polypropylene(PP) of reinforcing it
with glass, minerals, and natural fibers is critical performance-enhancing
option. But the effort remains complex, with numerous cross-currents
at work, buffeting the PP compounder and end-user alike.
PP is often described as "a least fussy resin" in terms
of its willingness to mate with shorter long-glass fibers, talc,
mica, and calcium carbonate particles, or the fast-expanding range
of natural fibers (other than wood flour) now being explored or
employed in many roles. PP's versatility is vastly extended by today's
diverse extender-reinforces. For instance, special compounders draw
on talc and CaCOł to elevate stiffness, increase dimensional stability
and hike thermal resistance in bumper fascia, electrical appliances
and dishwashers. Reinforced PP is a key to replacing ABS, filled
nylon, thermosets, and metals.
But the most momentous development in PP compounds is a novel group
of base resins. They are high-crystallinity PP, nucleated PP, and
metallocence PP, all enhancers of PP's conventional properties that
allow typical filler levels to be cut by as much as 50%. The trend
to these grades is strongest in Europe mostly in appliances and
bumper fascia.
Fillers however, impose considerable penalties. Mineral fillers,
for example, typically have over twice the density of neat PP, working
against the grain in automotive markets, where emphasis is on lightweighting.
In interior trim, deficiencies in gloss, odor, and scratch-resistance
are linked to talcs.
As a counterpoint, compounding tools that stretch property envelopes
are becoming readily available for PP. A notable one is long-glass-reinforced
PP, which boosts toughness and stiffness of PP to unprecedented
levels. Thus, LNP Engineering Plastics,Exton, PA, claims its long-glass
Verton MFX structural PP offers typical notched Izod values of 5
to 6 ft-lb/in, plus a flexural modulus of 1 million to 1.5 million
psi. Grades have a density 15% lower than that of glass-filled nylon.
Further, long-glass PP can be molded into parts using less complex
and less costly process than the ones used for glass-mat-reinforced
PP. Potential downsides are glass-fiber orientation, part distortion,
surface quality debits, and a cost about double that of short-glass
PP (and equal to that of short-glass nylon.)
Compounders have always used fillers to improve PP. The appliance
and auto industries are inveterate users, along with oriented PP
film extruders and thermoformers of microwave trays. Presently building
panels are increasingly using talc filled PP in place of PVC in
profiles, especially in Europe.
Estimates are that 25% of all PP used globally has a filler or
reinforcer of some kind. Kline & Co., a Little Falls, NJ, consultant,
pegs U.S. use of mineral reinforcers alone at 190,000 CaCOł (30%).
Underlying demand growth is estimated at 5% yr. Some 70,000 tonnes/yr
of glass fiber is used as a reinforcer globally, with Europe using
about half of that.
New grades permit cost and weight savings
Bumper fascia are evidence of the role of today's novel PPs. Superior
inherent stiffness and toughness lead to that reduced loadings of
talc can achieve given levels of stiffness. Or a given loading can
be translated into thinwalled parts, thus reducing costs and the
inevitable tradeoffs (e.g., weight) linked to filler use. Montell
and other high-crystallinity PP is now widely used in Europe's thinwall
instrument panels and the trend is reaching the U.S. Europe's use
of mineral fillers in PP is changing due to "new degrees of
freedom" realized by high-crystallinity PP. Over the past five
years, typically talc loadings have fallen about 50% to their present
levels of around 12% for instrument panels (IP) and 8 to 10% for
inner door panels where benefits include lower weight, better scratch
resistance, and reduced cost.
Borealis has developed "multispot" technology for interior
auto trim. This achieves a fabric-like effect by tailoring minerals
and loading levels. An early application is in the Opel Astra. Talc-filled
PP with a controlled coefficient of expansion is being used in a
Class A bumper fascia for Mercedes-Benz. Borealis as well as Targor
have launched scratch resistant PP compounds aimed at interior auto
parts. Metallocene grades are being sampled as a potential tool
for elevating stiffness and toughness a notch beyond that for high-crystallinity
PP. But metallocene-PP's role in durables is unclear, given that
its transparency appears irrelevant in target markets, while cost
premiums are high.
Another promising approach in fillers is nanoparticles, or sub-micron
clay particles that when dispersed well can beef up a composite's
toughness, barrier and other properties. Montell and General Motors
are working to apply these in autos, but skeptics view this as a
long-term hope, due to the high cost of nanocomposites. Others say
non-polar PP may be more resistant to efficient use of these particles
than nylons (the focus of most development work).
Reinforced PPs have long played major roles in electrical appliances
and white goods. While noting that talc loadings are down due to
use of novel PP, mineral-filled grades are crucial to ensure stiffness,
dimensional stability, and opacity.
Complex, load bearing parts like washing machine tubs, gears, and
bearings are in rapid transition from metals to reinforced PPs,
which offer excellent chemical resistance and facilitate parts integration.
Europe's market, is divided into tiers: Chopped glass PP is used
in the high-spin tub models (800 to 1500 rpm), while talc-filled
PP is favored in lower-end (under 800 rpm) models. Visible parts
like detergent trays, sieves, and fixtures use mostly talc filled
PP. In the predominant top-loading washing machines in Europe, PP
tends to discolor in visible parts, with some dire effects. In response,
both Targor and Borealis have launched grades highly resistant to
attack by detergents in hot water.
Europe is the leader in converting washing-machine tubs to short-glass-reinforced
PP. That same trend is now apparent in the U. S. An advantage is
gained in the alloying of multimineral and glass packages in PP
as a way to balance cost with required strength or shrinkage levels.
Ferro's Gapex reinforced PPs are also being tailored to reduce shrinkage,
so they closely match rates of ABS, PC, and PC/ABS. As a result,
existing molds can be used to run these PPs. The refrigerator door
handle as a classic illustration of the "diversity of materials
and processes" being trapped by PP compounders today. In the
part, four top U.S. manufacturers use chopped-glass PP in coinjection
(20% glass), gas-assist (10% glass) and foam.
Color matching is critical in small appliances, automotive, and
other uses, and more complex when a reinforced PP is used. Case
in point: the base color of talcs can vary widely between deposits
and even within a deposit; producers have to use sophisticated blending
to consistently match color. But Ferro, Hanna, A. Schulman Akron,
OH, and others are drawing on extensive color expertise to supply
solutions.
A decade ago, the favored practice of processors and OEMs was to
buy pre-colored PP compounds. This obviated difficulties in handling
and inventory of the low-bulk-density powders, but it imposed a
considerable cost premium. In these cost- driven times, self-coloring
of filled PPs (color concentrate fed directly at the extruder) has
become an imperative for many large end-users (e.g., OEMS) willing
to invest in necessary feeding equipment. M. A. Hanna's Max-batch
line of filled and colored masterbatches, for instance, makes this
feasible, while its Controlled Color Natural compounds are aimed
at automotive injection molders, physical properties, and reduced
inventory. Reinforced PP grades from M.A. Hanna are used by Nailite,
Chicago, IL, to mold UV-stable architectural panels, and Crotty
Corp., Quincy, MA, to ensure consistent color in sunroof visors.
For feeding low-aspect-ratio fillers (talc and CaCOł ) directly,
Hanna has a new masterbatch technology using letdown techniques
comparable to those used to introduce color at the press. This allows
end-users to buy lower-cost, unfilled base resin instead of a press-ready
compound says Larry Stover, Hanna's technology vp. Upto 80% filler
content is possible; cost savings are put at 5 to 20%.
Mineral fillers are improving dramatically, as finer, whiter, easier-to-color
minerals appear, and chemically coupled, functionalized reinforcers
are coming into play too. High-brightness talcs from China are used
in both auto and appliance parts where color match is vital. Luzenac's
Cimpact 610C and 710C grades, the first of these in concentrated
forms, are said to improve handling, workplace safety, and dispersion.
These realize cost saving: the 1 to 2˘/lb higher cost is outweighed
by 20 to 40% higher compounding rate.
Odor is a growing issue for talcs in autos and also in interior
and hot-air ducting parts. But a new Luzenac coating technology
is said to thermally stabilize talc particles, thus greatly reducing
potential odor.
Specialty Minerals, Bethlehem, PA, reports that calcined talcs
offer an improvement in scratch resistance viz-a-viz conventional
ones, and are most often used in blends to keep cost down. The launch
of Microtuff AGD, a family of densified fine talcs that beef up
thermal performance and appearance, are easy to handle, and boost
compounding rates by up to 300%.
Long-glass-reinforced PP has already made inroads in performance
roles against engineering resins globally. Current uses are auto
mirror brackets, battery supports and truck cooling fans. Industrial
applications include power tool housings, vibration absorbers for
snowboards and mountain bikes as well as loudspeaker cones.
A benefit noted by LNP is its ability to harmonize a materials
system when supporting new design. A tool maker in East Greenwich,
RI, has developed a coil-fed screw gun that allows 167 screws to
be installed automatically. This taps not only LNP's glass-fiber
PP for housing and adapter, which yields weight savings and cost
reduction, but also its lubricated, reinforced nylon, optimizes
mating with the PP part. Growth for LNP's materials is pegged at
30% /yr in Europe and about 12% in the U.S. In automotive, shift
to larger parts and integrated modules is favorable to long glass
PP. Findlen cites front-end assemblies, IPs, and loadbearing floor
systems. A recent addition to LNP's line includes a "cosmetic
black" grade, MSX UV Black, a 30% glass grade for exterior
(weatherable) door handles. Breakthroughs have occurred in combining
long-glass PP with variants of injection molding. One is injection
compression molding, a gentle process that retains the length and
integrity of long glass fibers. Another new approach is structural
foam mold in which structures of 10 to 35% glass PP and a 65 to
90% endothermic foam core are made. And gas-assist techniques are
being applied in glass-reinforced PP.
After prevailing in a legal fight to practice long-glass reinforcement,RTP
Co., Winona, MI, is reaffirming its role. The company supplies Europe
directly from Beaune, France. RTP's grades are "excellent replacements
for metal, particularly diecast parts where costly or time-consuming
secondary steps are used," says the company. RTP puts emphasis
on chemical coupling of long glass in its RTP 100CC series. Tensile
strength of 30% coupled-glass in said to top an unmodified PP by
180%, and a conventional glass-reinforced PP by 50%.
Appryl Composites, a venture of Atochem and Multibase, St-Laurent
DuPont, France, focuses Prylex long-glass fiber PP on automotive
use. It supplies grades from a 4000-ton/yr facility in Dieuze, France,
for use in bumper beam battery support, and non-visible interior
parts. Appryl has a long-fiber (12-mm) grade for visible interior
trim, countering a prior handicap. Typically, long fibers tend to
migrate to surfaces, impairing appearance. A novel additive, however,
distributes fibers at the core rather than at the surface, holding
them. Appryl's cites a success. Initially, the interior storage
bin frames in the Renault Scenic used short-glass fiber PP with
carpet overlay, a costly approach. But using long-glass PP allowed
molding of the part without the carpet.
Conversion from glass-mat-reinforced PP to long-glass PP is being
witnessed in Europe, being driven by better overall economics, plus
weight reduction and parts integration. Growth could be pegged at
15 to 20%/yr. Shortage-glass PP, meanwhile has good prospects too,
according to Montell, which offers the material. Its cost is about
half that of long-glass PP. Montell has introduced a blow moldable
version, using one of its high-melt-strength PPs as the base resin.
Natural fiber use in Europe is driven by environmental considerations
and to a lesser extent its lower density viz-a-viz talcs, says Targor's
Sondern. He does note deficits for jute, flax, kenaf (hibiscus),
and other natural fibers: they tend to degrade at or near processing
temperatures typical for pp, and they absorb moisture. A study of
the potential of wheat and rice straw states availability and cost
of crop residues are favorable. Their use of fillers has a special
appeal in the developing regions, such as China and Africa. A potential
use is in building panels.
|