Speech by Mr PP Kharas, President
OPPon 27 Aug 2004 at the AGM of OPPI
One of the most critical issues facing the
Plastics Processors is the sharply spiraling
prices of commodity Polymers. The side effects
of this price spiral on the Plastics Processing
sector may turn out to be very severe, in terms
of industrial sickness, demand-recession and
dwindling employment. The gravity of this situation
can be understood better when you consider that
the Plastics Processing industry is in a very
unenviable position: between the very large
somewhat monopolistic raw material producers
on one side and on the other side, by consumers
who now have a wide range of choices for industrial
products, durable and household goods.
Historically, plastics processed products have
suffered from a combination of customs duties,
excise duties and sales tax levies alongwith
other Policy restraints, that have served to
retard the growth of Plastics applications by
creating artificial barriers and preventing
its wider use in those applications which are
of vital use to Nation building.
During the past 15 months there has been a
significant increase in the prices of domestic
polymers. The increase, depending on the polymer,
varies from a high of 91% to 43%. The international
prices have also increased significantly more
or less in the same proportion as domestic prices.
OPP and the other Associations have made representations
to the Ministry of Finance for reduction in
import duty on Polymers from 20% to 10% of CIF.
Naturally, this is cause for worry and concern
particularly when nobody is willing to predict
at what level the price escalation will stabilize
and when. In a complex situation such as the
one that we are faced with, each business unit
will need to make its own decisions, and prepare
for the future, based on an on-going review
of facts as they emerge over time. I have tried
to make a beginning by providing some basic
facts as I have read or known them and by making
sense of the opinions expressed by knowledgeable
Friends in the Industry. The facts as stated
are by no means complete, and their validity
is open for review.
OIL & GAS:
To understand the price situation on
Polymers, I believe it is necessary to have
atleast an elementary perspective on crude oil,
naphtha and gas. The National Geographic Magazine's
June 2004 edition reviews the current status
of crude oil production world-wide, and concludes
that "the days of cheap oil are over";
that world production will most likely peak
about 2016, but outside the Middle East even
earlier around 2006. The timing, it says rests
largely on the behaviour of the Middle East
producers; also on moves to find new reserves,
and to develop unconventional sources, such
as Canada's tar sands.
It is clear from various reports that three factors
have contributed to the current price levels of
crude, (which are today at twice the levels prevailing
in Dec. 2001):
 |
Increasing global
energy demand, including from China. - Crude
oil consumption rose by 1.5 million b.p.d.,
and will grow further by 2.4 million b.p.d.
to a level of 80 million b.p.d. in 2004. |
 |
Disruptions in supply; from
Venezuela, Nigeria, Iraq and the bankruptcy
problem of Russian major "Yukos",
the largest Russian oil producer. (Russia
is next only to Saudi Arabia in oil production). |
 |
The terrorist threat of disruption
in supplies in the Middle East. |
Some analysts believe that there is currently
very little spare capacity with OPEC; some others
state that OPEC producers are not making efforts
to look for additional reserves, which geologists
believe are present. When supplies outside the
Middle East start to dwindle in about 20 years,
the Middle East will again be a predominant supplier
of one-half to two-third's of the world requirement
- the same percentage as before the 1973 oil embargo.
India produces about 33 million MT of crude
oil annually, against a requirement of 115 million
MT. The Country's annual import bill is around
US $ 20 billion (Rs.93,500 crore). Naphtha,
a fraction derived from crude oil refining,
is the starting point for producing the "building
blocks", (ethylene, propylene etc.) for
polymers. India is a net exporter of naphtha.
Consistent with the increase in crude oil prices,
the international prices for Naphtha have increased
from US $ 222 per tonne in May 2003, to US $
420 per tonne to date, an increase of 90%.
To understand the basic differences in production
costs in Asia-Pacific, Middle East and Europe/USA
the following facts are relevant :
"Majority of the Ethylene crackers are
based on Naphtha feedstock. Global feedstock
share for Ethylene production was : Naphtha
54%, Ethane 29% and other feedstocks like propane,
butane, gas oil 17%. In the Asia Pacific region,
83% of the Ethylene capacity is Naphtha based;
however, in the Middle East 69% Ethylene capacity
is based on Ethane. In India, 60% of the petrochemical
plant capacity uses naphtha as the feedstock
and the remaining 40% are gas based. In India,
while the cost of Ethylene from gas based crackers
is relatively low, India does not have adequate
availability of gas. The recent finds of gas
in the Krishna-Godavari basin will nearly double
the availability. The relative yield of Ethylene
is 78% and 32% in Ethane based and Naphtha based
crackers respectively. However, yield of bye-products
(Propylene, Butadiene, Benzene, Toulene, MixC4,
etc.) is more in Naphtha crackers." The
cost of ethane and therefore ethylene in the
Middle East is around 25% to 30% of that in
the U.S.A. Whereas the variations in the cost
of ethylene from Naphtha crackers around the
World is not so wide --- in the range of 25%
|